BBA Challenge Challah

The Week 6 BBA Challenge bread is Challah, a traditional Jewish braided egg bread. Unlike Cindy at Salt and Serenity, who has been making Challah weekly for the past 12 years, until this challenge, I had never made Challah. I think I’ve eaten it before, but even that would have been 25 years ago when my family took a trip to Israel. So I approached this challenge with both the excitement of trying something new and the trepidation of jumping in blind.

The bread itself is a fairly straightforward egg dough, so I wasn’t concerned about that. What made me a bit nervous, however, was the thought of braiding the dough. Although I have been baking for about 30 years, I’ve never braided bread dough, and I wasn’t sure how it would work out. I received a lot of encouragement from other BBAers, so I figured I’d dive in and have a go at it.

If you’ve read any of my other BBA blog posts, you know I don’t do things the simple way. For example, I made all three versions of brioche. So it shouldn’t surprise you to note that, even though I was nervous about the braiding, I decided to make two versions of Challah — a traditional yeasted bread, and a sourdough version.

For the sourdough version, I fed up Adrian to about 15 ounces, of which I used 14 ounces for the Challah, and the remaining ounce to feed and store for later. I keep Adrian at 100% hydration, so by using 14 ounces I replaced 7 ounces each of flour and water in the original recipe. I omitted the yeast from the dry mixture and didn’t add any additional water to the egg and oil mixture.

Sourdough Challah Ingredients

I took Adrian out of the refrigerator about an hour before I mixed up the dough, but the starter was still quite chilly. Because I didn’t add any additional water (I ended up mixing in quite a bit of flour during the kneading stage), I wasn’t able to adjust the dough temperature by using warm water. So after the mixing, the dough was still quite cool. This was fine with me, as I like to use a long ferment with sourdough to build in as much flavor as possible. However, I didn’t want it to be an all-day process, either, so I fermented the dough in my “proofing box“.

Microwave Proofing Box

By increasing the temperature and humidity, I was able to kick start the fermentation process. It still took the dough longer to rise than the yeasted dough, which you would expect with sourdough.

While the sourdough Challah was fermenting, I mixed the yeasted Challah per the recipe. I again had to add extra flour during the kneading process, and I ended up with a beautiful, golden dough that was supple but not at all sticky. I fermented this dough at room temperature, and it rose beautifully.

After degassing and the second ferment, I divided the yeasted dough into three pieces. It is important that the dough pieces be of equal size for braiding, so I weighed the dough and then scaled each piece.

Challah Dough

Dividing Challah Dough

Then I preshaped the pieces into boules and set them aside to rest.

Challah Dough - Divided and Rounded

After a 10-minute rest (for me and the dough), I began rolling the dough into ropes. I wanted to make the ropes about the length of my Silpat, as that would give me plenty of length to work with when braiding. The dough resisted rolling and tried to pull back quite a bit, so I set the ropes, which were about half the length I wanted, aside and let them rest for another 10 minutes. This allowed the dough to relax and made it easier to roll out into ropes.

First attempt at rolling out ropes

First attempt at rolling out ropes

Ropes, after a 10-minute rest

Ropes, after a 10-minute rest

Once I got the ropes rolled to the length I wanted, I was ready to try my hand at braiding. I read, reread, and read again PR’s directions for a 3-strand braid. It sounded simple enough. Starting in the middle, you cross one of the outside strands over the center strand, then do the same from the other side. Once you have braided half the dough, you turn it around and braid the other end.

3-Strand Braid - so far, so good

3-Strand Braid - so far, so good

For the second half, you tuck the braids under the center, rather than taking them over the top. Again, it seemed easy enough, and before I knew it, I had what looked like a respectable Challah on my hands. The braids weren’t quite as tight as they might have been, but for my first time, I was pleased. I set the dough aside to proof for an hour or so, then sprinkled it with poppy seeds and preheated the oven.

Challah - Braided with Poppy Seeds

I baked the loaf at 350 degrees for 20 minutes, then took it out to rotate the pan. I was surprised by how done the loaf appeared, so at this point, I inserted my probe thermometer before returning the loaf to the oven.

Challah with Probe Thermometer

For those of you not familiar with a probe thermometer, it is a thermometer that sits on the counter with a probe that can be stuck into a loaf of bread or piece of meat. The probe has a long wire on it, so whatever you are baking or roasting can be put into the oven with the probe in it, and you can monitor the temperature by looking at the unit sitting on the counter. Most probe thermometers, in addition to showing the internal temperature of your bread, also allow you to set the desired temperture. When the loaf reaches the correct internal temperature, an alarm will sound, telling you that it is done. Although the recipe said the loaf would take another 20 to 45 minutes to finish baking, my loaf reached 190 degrees in the center in about 7 more minutes.

Meanwhile, back to the sourdough Challah. After degassing the dough, I set it aside for the second ferment, which was supposed to take about an hour, according to the recipe. I put my dough in a measuring bowl (as seen in the proofing box picture above) so I could tell when it had increased to 1 1/2 time its original size. I wasn’t surprised that it took longer than an hour, and indeed it took almost 3 hours to reach the desired size.

Flush with my yeasted Challah braiding success, I decided to up the ante and try a 4-strand braid with the sourdough Challah. So I divided the dough into 4 equal pieces, rested them and rolled them out into ropes.

Sourdough Challah Divided into Boules

Sourdough Challah 4 Ropes

Following the directions for a 4-strand braid (or so I thought), I joined the ropes at the top and began braiding, 4 over 2, 1 over 3, 2 over 3, and on and on.

Sourdough Challah Braiding

It wasn’t until I was more than halfway through braiding that I realized I had somehow left one of the strands completely out of the braiding process. I ended up with a lovely, 3-strand braid sitting on top of a straight rope.

Sourdough Challah Braided

I went ahead an baked it. It came out a little lopsided, as the straight rope sort of tipped over the braid. Unfortunately, I didn’t get a picture of the finished product. We were on our way out the door to a dinner party, to which I was taking both loaves. My dining companions and I had a good laugh about my braiding techniques, but everyone (including a couple who had lived in Israel for a while) agreed that the Challahs were a success. We didn’t notice much of a difference between the sourdough and yeasted loaves, except that the sourdough had a slightly softer crust.

All in all, I would call both Challah loaves a success. And I’m no longer afraid of braiding. In fact, I’m anxious to try a 4-strand braid again, to see how it looks when you use all 4 ropes!


  1. June 30, 2009 at 11:16 am

    I’m always so impressed with your breads! Congrats on this one…the four-braid looked lovely, too. Cheers …

    • gaaarp said,

      June 30, 2009 at 11:24 pm

      Thanks! I really enjoyed making these breads.

  2. Maris said,

    June 30, 2009 at 1:27 am

    Both of these look great! Your braids are so precise – amazing! I had to wrestle mine into a braid but it tasted good in the end!

  3. Tammy said,

    June 29, 2009 at 7:13 pm

    Wow! I loved that you made two. They both look awesome! I used 4 strand but braided it into a ball (round)

    Nicole recommended your challah blog on her’s

  4. Kimberly said,

    June 29, 2009 at 6:33 pm

    I need to try Reinhart’s version. Having done Tamar Ansch’s challah has been quite ian experience given that the ratios are huge quantities and her recipe does not have egg actually in it. I think I made Reinhart’s with egg once, but don’t have a photo of it handy to post. Ansh’s book though does teach how to braid several different ways.

  5. June 29, 2009 at 4:18 pm

    […] Challah from Of Cabbages and King Cakes […]

  6. Di said,

    June 21, 2009 at 12:30 pm

    Nice job. I hope to get to my challah this week. Fortunately, I have lots of practice braiding, though dough is a bit different to braid than hair. =)

  7. misterrios said,

    June 18, 2009 at 5:43 pm

    Awesome three-on-top-of-one strand. I would have done the exact same thing.

    • gaaarp said,

      June 18, 2009 at 6:31 pm

      Thanks for the solidarity! The funny thing is that I’m not actually sure what I did wrong. I’ll have to try it again and see if I can figure it out.

  8. strangerkiss said,

    June 18, 2009 at 1:00 am

    I can’t wait to try the Challah. I’ve done the Anadama and the Artos (which is in the oven right this minute). Your bread is beautiful. Even the “4” braid one. Thanks for sharing your mistake – it helps others to avoid them.

    And very impressive that you made all three brioches and two challahs!

  9. June 16, 2009 at 2:10 pm

    Always fun to know what someone else has tried before or like you with the braid, hasn’t done before. It really is super pretty bread isn’t it. Gorgeous color on your loaf.

  10. oggi said,

    June 16, 2009 at 1:53 pm

    The baked loaf looks perfect! I’ll use sourdough for my next challah.

  11. AnneMarie said,

    June 15, 2009 at 10:34 am

    I saw someone who braided it into a ball. I’ve done a three strand braid before, may try the four. Your loaf looks beautiful.

    • gaaarp said,

      June 16, 2009 at 9:10 pm

      From the pictures in BBA, it looks like the 2-strand braid comes out kind of like a ball. I might try that the next time I do a braided bread.

  12. raidar said,

    June 15, 2009 at 10:24 am

    Congrats. That looks wonderful!

  13. Flour Girl said,

    June 15, 2009 at 10:13 am

    Those look great! Even the 4-strand-turned-3-strand one. I’ve only made challah a few times before, so I’m hoping mine turn out as lovely as yours. Good work!

  14. AJM said,

    June 15, 2009 at 1:31 am

    I’m sure someone has already said this but I can’t help myself:

    YO, ADRIAN!!!!

    Now that I’ve gotten that out of my system, great looking challah! I have been using a meat thermometer on my bread but I think I need to invest in a probe for more accuracy

  15. June 14, 2009 at 8:21 pm

    You are so innovative – a sourdough challah! I’m surprised it didn’t taste very different from the yeasted one. For a first attempt at braiding, I am very impressed. It looks great. I had to laugh at your 4 strand – oh well, mistakes are how we learn. Thanks for mentioning my blog. Have a great week.

    • gaaarp said,

      June 14, 2009 at 8:23 pm

      Thanks, Cindy. I think the sourdough wasn’t much different because I used it “fresh”, which is to say I used it soon after feeding it, so it hadn’t had time to develop a strong sour flavor.

  16. Kayte said,

    June 14, 2009 at 8:17 pm

    Looks so great…and two varieties, too. You are now qualified to put braiding on your resume. Probe thermometer, check, putting that on my wish list. Finished an absolutely beautiful color!

    • gaaarp said,

      June 14, 2009 at 8:22 pm

      Thanks, Kayte. I was pretty happy with both loaves.

      I used to use my instant read thermometer to check all my loaves, but I’ve found lately that I like to put the probe thermometer in the bread when I rotate it. It ensures that you take it out of the oven at exactly the right time. With the instant read, sometimes the bread it overdone by the time I take it out (if only by a few degrees) or I have to stick it back in for a while and check again.

  17. Susie said,

    June 14, 2009 at 8:02 pm

    You did great. So pretty.
    Nice to be baking along with you.

    • gaaarp said,

      June 14, 2009 at 8:22 pm

      Thanks, Susie. I’m enjoying reading your posts and baking with you, too.

  18. Nicole said,

    June 14, 2009 at 7:49 pm

    Yay! This week I’ll be braiding my very first loaf, too. I’ll probably just do a straightforward three-strand braid, but I’d like to try something more complicated in the future!

    • gaaarp said,

      June 14, 2009 at 8:18 pm

      Actually, I don’t think the 4-strand is that complicated. I’m not sure what I did, but in theory it’s not much different than the 3-strand.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: